Fight comment spam, earn cash!

You have certainly seen comments on websites or blogs like these before:

"I found your website by accident and really like it. Please also visit my site, where you can get free [anything], please click here http://mycoolwebsite.com/..."

Many people already got used to deleting spam comments from their blogs or even totally disabled the comment feature. This weekend I read about an approach from a german blogger which I'd like to share with the english-speaking communuity.

One year ago, he added the following line just before the SUBMIT button in the comment area:

"Dear spammers, advertising comments will cost you € 1400 a month".

Wow... he was probably inspired by the can deposit system in Germany. They don't want you to buy Coke in cans, so there is an extra charge of 25 cent per can, that you get back if you return the can. Almost nobody does it, so now Coke cans have almost disappeared from the shops. You change things if it pays off to people or if they have expenses if they act inapropriate. Martin (the german blogger) didn't intend to make money from it, he just wanted to have clean blog comments. For each spam comment he sent a bill to the owner of the linked website, and suddenly a bunch of scared spammers let him know through their lawyers that it wasn't them who posted the comment etc. So he scared away some of the spammers, some at least had to pay their lawyers and some simply apologized and promised not to spam his blog anymore.

Now after one year Martin removed the line from the comment box. I translated his post for you:

reason ONE: too many people copied my idea without thinking about it. Some even contacted me and asked for tips and legal advice on how to they could scare spammers out of fun. I wanted to make the world better, not worse.

reason TWO - and this one is the important one: I got to know a lot of spammers. They can be divided into two categories:

1. the industrial spammers create hundreds of automated comments in a second from different IP addresses, sometimes hundreds of comments per day. They are mostly located overseas, my bills would have been useless.
2. professional spammers are smart ass mafiosi, act alone but are part of a network and post comments by hand supported by half automatic scripts. If they are located in the local market (Germany), the bills worked (but they knew their rights and sent letters of objection). Most of all the line itself ("you have to pay for spam comments") worked and scared away many. We need to fight those kind of people, unfortunately they almost don't show up at my site anymore.
3. the self made man spammers. I can't explain the reason, only describe what I'm seeing: more and more I get to know people that run their own websites and try to make money from it, often supported by Google Adsense. Most of them live off that business and the stories they're telling me cause me pain in my heart. They started it from an emergency situation, often because their unemployment insurance wouldn't pay anymore, no chance for a real job, and [...] being their own boss was the only hope to get some money. They only have limited or almost no clue about the internet or even the communicative processes inside it, they just heard that "you need links for your business to work"[...]
   

But I only wanted to explain, why I am not sending bills anymore. Voilá, here's the answer: it doesn't help. That means - like I wrote: with professional spammers it doesn't help much. But I am really sorry for the impact on small business makers who don't know better and have problems enough already and shouldn't be bothered by angry bill-sending blogwriters.

I am sorry if my translation was maybe not 100%, but I hope you get the point.

I think you could try fighting professional comment spam by transforming a comment box into a place where you start something like a contract with the person commenting, at least for the local market:

• Use Captcha's to prevent comments placed by robots and ensure that a human being wrote the lines
  

• state clearly that you charge for spam comments, but make sure normal people are not irritated by that and are happy to leave their 2 cents on your page
  

• have the user type "I AGREE" in a blank field, otherwise you wouldn't accept the comment

You might also need some help from lawyers.

Be good, don't harm surfers!

image by opticallyactive, used unter cc license.

technorati tags: commentspam, spam, blogging, antispam

The new age of virtualization

I discovered vmware six years ago, and I knew it could change the way we do technial support and QA entirely. You can easily create as many different machines as you wish, one with Win98, WinME, Win2k, WinXP, all in different releases, languages, patch levels... and for your testing you simply switch on the machine you need.

Even before the release of the GSX/ESX servers I took the workstation edition to set up a pool of different machines hosted on a huge Linux box. Each of them had a vncserver installed, so you could connect to the machine of your choice from your desktop.

I started with VMware workstation 2.0 and already this piece of software was a killer application. Since that time - we reached version 5.5 now - we got many new features and more hardware support.

The biggest change now is the licensing issue. You might have been able to talk your boss into buying you one license for vmware, but I bet it was almost impossible having him supply the entire team with that tool. Now VMware Player was released - and it's free! It is meant for running already configured virtual machines you created with the full product or you downloaded from a supplier like Novell, Redhat or Ubuntu.

It was just a matter of days until the world was told how to use the free tool to legally build and run your individual virtual machine. And indeed, how would you define "preconfigured machine"? Now even a new tool lets you create vm machines from the scratch, where you can configure RAM, disks, hardware support etc. - and upgrades your free player to a full product. Well - almost. The workstation edition offers a lot more stuff, especially the multiple possibilites to handle virtual disks. For example, you can tell vmware to discard all changes made to the virtual disk when powering off.

Why is VMware Player free? These guys must be nuts! Or quite smart :) At the SYSTEMS 2005 in Munich I had the chance to talk to one guy from VMware. They are totally aware what the community is doing with the free player, but on one hand they recently got some competition, and on the other side they hope that reasonable people appreciate the free tool and will be interested in supporting development by buying the full product for creation, and using the free tool company-wide for using the virtual machines.

VMware is pure fun, and it saves your life in tech support and QA.

technorati tags: vmware

Your internet workplace inside a Unix terminal

We talked about remote desktops before. It's not that easy, using your remote applications on your local machine, mostly you need a complex architecture or installed software.

You might have used PuTTY before, a text mode terminal emulation for Windows you can use to connect to Unix/Linux boxes.

Ever thought about using a terminal like this to get your things done?

Here is a list of interesting tools:

1. Multi sessions: screen - works like a virtual desktop manager for Windows/KDE, here you open just one terminal, but you can create as many additional screens as you like, you toggle between them with hot keys and so can use many tools at the same time
   
2. Read your emails: mutt - email client with many features. You can read your local inbox, imap and pop3 mailboxes, send emails and attachments
3. Surf the web: links2 - text mode browser
   
4. instant messaging: centericq - fantastic text mode client that connects you to your buddies at Yahoo, MSN, ICQ, AIM and Jabber.
5. rss feed reader: raggle / snownews - two good feed aggregators
6. downloaders: ctorrent / curl - access to the torrent network and file downloader
7. blogging engine: nanoblogger - write and maintain your blog inside the shell
   

If you set up these tools on your shell account, you are able to connect to your workplace from anywhere in the world, no matter if that machine is running Windows, Linux, MacOs, or Unix. And all traffic between your local box and your remote workplace is encrypted.

technorati tags: unix, shell, terminal

How to get your remote desktop

In old times, client workstations have been quite dumb. All programs and data was stored on big servers, and the people accessed it from thin clients at their work desks.
With the rise of the desktop pc the client became more intelligent - which lead us to problems in software distribution, driver installations, backups and many more.

Recently, the art of working remote is being rediscovered. Most of work can be done in the browser already, and every day new services come up where we can collaborate on documents, edit and manipulate photos or manage projects. More and more it becomes irrelevant, which operating system your client is running, Firefox is everywhere.

Some years ago I signed up for WorkSpot, a paid service that offers remote linux desktops to which you could connect to with a small java applet in the browser a VNC client. I could access my workplace with word processor, email, messenger, bookmarks and newsfeeds easily from any internet cafe or other place I wanted. And it was great for showing people new things without having to install stuff on their box.

Then, WorkSpot started to have massive problems. Every once in a while, the servers were down, sessions wouldn't start, or they wouldn't install the latest version of gaim so it would work with the redesigned protocols of Yahoo and MSN. WorkSpot seems to be off business now. Their idea was really great.

Now CosmoPod is doing the same thing, the only difference seems to be that they're using NX instead of VNC to connect. Talking about connecting - it didn't work for me. There are too many users out there, or some freaks already smashed it down. Some time ago I thought about coming up with a service like that, but I didn't.

This are the issues with a general remote desktop service

• availability: people will probably not use their desktops 100% of time, but when they need it, it must work. Things like that cause heavy loads on the host systems and you need to watch it 24/7.
  
• backups: how to explain to your clients that all data is lost - but at least the service is free?
  
• security: making a webserver secure is quite hard. Making a unix system safe from users bothering each other or sniffing around is almost impossible.
  
• third party software: many people - many different ways of working and software to be used. There will be discussions like "Why is that software installed, but not that one?"
  

So if you're serious, forget about free remote desktops. Unless a big player like Google offers it - but also here you should think about what you do.

Here is what you can do to get your remote desktop and you don't want to have that box running under your bed:

• rent a cheap virtual server (vserver, based on Virtuozzo technology) from your favourite hosting company. In Germany, you can get one with 1 GB harddisk and 5 GB traffic for 3 $ per month.
• deactivate all services like http, smtp etc.
  
• install kde, firefox, open office, gaim, .. all the things you need
• set up VNC and connect to your individual remote machine
• if you want to be on the safer side, start the VNC service only when you need to use your desktop.
  

Update:
A more secure and also very interesting solution is the following:

• get your own virtual Linux box as described before.
• Linux is a networking operating system. We tend to forget that when talking about desktops and think of it as a simple Windows replacement. So instead of having your entire desktop remotely - why not simply focus on the applications you REALLY need?
• for this you need an X server running on your local machine. The best one for Windows is Cygwin - and it's free.
• now we can open gui applications (like Firefox, OpenOffice, Gaim,...) that run on another Linux machine anywhere in the world on our box. Your desktop will be local, just this very application you need is hosted remotely.
• for this you start your local X server and allow other hosts to open a window. Issue xhost + on the cygwin shell
  
• open a secure shell to the remote box. You have to enable X11-forwarding, PuTTY can do that
• PuTTY will have set a $DISPLAY variable for you on the remote shell if everything worked. Otherwise you might have to switch on X11-forwarding in the SSH-Server on the remote box
• now you can simply start a program of your choice, e.g. Firefox in the secure shell and if you listened closely you shouldn't have any trouble.
• the cool thing here is, that all traffic between your local desktop and the application is tunneled through the secure shell and so automatically encrypted
• try replacing the remote shell from /bin/bash to /bin/firefox. It's fun!
  

I know these are no quick solutions and you also need to have some basic unix administration skills - or at least the phone number of someone who can do it for you.

create newsfeeds for sites that don't have one

crazy about newsfeeds? Well, I am. How could I possibly stay tuned to new stuff on the web without my feed subscriptions. Instead of checking the websites for new articles, I prefer them telling me when there is something interesting.

A lot of websites still don't offer newsfeeds - for different reasons. FeedTier is your friend here, it is still beta, but it analyzes pages you submit and it makes an rss feed from it. Works great if you want to watch e.g. all incoming Jackie Chan DVDs on ebay.

P.S.: I had the identical idea for a project also, but was too busy working on other things. There is also this great misbelief, that we're the only one on the planet who could possibly come up with "this great new idea". What do we learn? You really need to be quick with ideas on the web. Otherwise someone else is bought by Yahoo, Google & Co.